The butterfly gives him more rope.

The night after he told me he took me for granted The Neighbor knocked on my door at 9:30. I was in my pajamas, had just lit some incense, Peyton was snoozing, and The Black Angels were playing. I opened the door and he stood in my doorway with his backpack over his shoulder, sweaty, and in his gym clothes.

I need you to sniff me,” he said and walked in. I let him pass and walk a few feet into my apartment, gingerly holding my wine glass out of the way.

“Ok,” I said and I leaned in to his neck and sniffed. He smelled clean, but sweaty. “You smell fine,” I told him and turned us around and herded him back to the front door.

Outside my open door I quickly added, “But I’m not sniffing your shorts. They’re fine.”

He looked at me mischievously and pulled out the waistband of his shorts and said, “I have something you can sniff.”

“No, thanks,” I replied succinctly. “Goodnight,” and I shut the door on him. But before I could close it all the way I saw his face split into utter shock, his mouth open, and he jammed his foot to prevent the door from shutting.

“What?? Really??” he asked incredulously.

“Yep. No, thanks. Goodnight!” I said again pushing against his foot.

“Uh… ok. Goodnight,” he relented and removed his foot. The door slammed resoundingly. I walked away with a smile and my chest puffed up.

That night began a week of an embargo on Me. My heart needs to heal and fortify. His words, “I take you for granted,” echo in my mind every hour of every day. How can I possibly recover from that? I give him every piece of me, yet get so very little in return. I am not allowed to talk about him with my friends or family; I may not rely on him; I have no overt control over when we hang out or the nature of those visits. The only way in which I’m allowed to connect with him is through acts of affection — which he determines based on his current mood and needs — and through my body, but I am limited even in that.

As he very honestly admitted to me that night, unwittingly, he cares for none of what I do or who I am. Frequently, and with pleasure, he tells me I may not have the only thing I’m allowed to ask of from him: his cock. I am alone and sinking in a frozen pond and he is waving at me from the shore, bundled up and warm.

It was a devastating blow, much like his “six strikes” comment, and I cannot unring that bell.

This week has been relatively easy. I’ve been distracted and engaged elsewhere and I’ve flitted in and out of his life with detached smiles and polite words. I’ve yet to have the pleasure of texting, “Sorry! Busy working on a project!” but I am ready, poised to parry.

Thursday night I had a dream of him. He’d told me he loved me and I knew it because he’d turned his doormat, which reads “Welcome”, around to face out properly. (I had turned it around weeks ago as a joke in real life.) We fucked and connected and my heart had soared in my sleep. He loved me! I’d thought. But then I crumpled and was fearful it was all a joke, possibly a mistake or a misunderstanding.

I couldn’t shake the dream yesterday and decided to tell him.

His response was, “Yeah, that’s crazy.”

“Outrageous,” I said dryly. “So this means you can never turn your mat around now hahaha (actually, I’m totally kidding in case you take me literally)” his logical, programming brain often misses the nuances of my sick sense of humor.

“I’m going to flip it over,” he typed back.

“Like upside down?”


So before I left the apartment that day I took the liberty of flipping it over myself. The word, “Welcome,” hidden from us both and a giggle in my throat. I thought it was incredibly funny and poignant.

Last night the grey clouds that had hung wet and heavy over the city all day spit and soaked the streets. The loamy smell of earth filled the world and the bugs sung as I wearily climbed the 40 steps with Peyton. I was bone weary and fighting a slow, blue sadness. And when I cleared the last set of stairs to my apartment, a little hand gripped in mine and out of breath from singing, “The Old Man is Snoring,” I saw TN’s mat rolled up inside out outside his door. It wasn’t enough to leave it flat as I’d left it. He had probably kicked it so its ends curled under.

Again, the message. Clear. Concise. Thanks. Was this supposed to be funny?

I took a deep breath and walked inside with Peyton and did the bedtime routine and prepared for my best friend to come over, my long week not yet over. This would be the first time I’d see her since the week of Fourth of July when TN shredded my heart.

She had abandoned me in my hour of need. I’d called her and begged her to come be with me multiple times and she had simply said, “No.” My response to this years long pattern between us was to pull back, spread out my needs among other friends who could be there for me — Internet Boyfriend most certainly included — and to simply wait and see what would happen between us. She did not rise to the occasion.

She remained distant and preoccupied with her own life. She confirmed her attendance to my birthday party and then simply never showed up and I didn’t hear from her for another week. My heart crusted over further as other friends showed their mettle and fortitude in my time of need and I began to move on. I simply could not close the gap between us anymore. It was clear that I only got a friendship out of her when I made the effort. She didn’t care.

But Friday afternoon she asked me what was really going on and I gently and honestly shared my feelings with her. She said she wanted to see me right away to talk. I agreed that once I was home I would let her know, so it was around 9:30 when I heard her knock and let her in.

She was distraught and strange looking, her eyes intense and watery. I assumed it was because she was broken-hearted over losing me, but in reality it was because her husband had put her in a choke-hold and thrown her across the garage to land in a heap on her side, her feet never touching the ground. She sobbed and apologized for having to talk about this horrible night instead of our friendship and with tears in my eyes and my heart pounding with rage I assured her it was ok, that I was there for her.

She cried harder. “Of course you are, Hy. You’re always there for me. Always. For every single major moment in my life you’ve been there and I have let you down for so long. I didn’t realize it until now how important you are to me. I love you more than anyone else and I want you in my life forever.”

I thanked her and hugged her and assured her we would be ok. I had never heard such beautiful words from anyone in my life. “You are so good, so kind. You give so, so much, and I am limited. I know that. You deserve more and I can’t promise to be as good a friend to you as you are to me, but I want you to know that it’s not because I don’t love you, it’s because I can’t handle things and I shut down. I wish I could be the same kind of friend to you. I’m going to work on it.”

The conversation turned to catching up. She was shocked and disappointed to learn that I had picked back up with TN. The last she’d known was when he’d left me for 4 am girl. I hung my head shamefully, sucking on a cigarette. “I know. It’s like we’re two rutting magnets. But back then the big deal breaker for me was when he’d said Peyton was ‘six strikes’ against me and then he took it all back and he’s been wonderful with my baby ever since.” She shook her head at me. “Don’t worry,” I quickly added, “he’s done it again, something I can’t forget. He told me he took me for granted.”

“Like I took you for granted,” she said quietly.

I only gave her a pained look of apologetic agreement.

“Hy, you have to stop letting us take advantage of you. I’m glad you did this with me, I’ll never do it again. We don’t deserve you if we don’t value what you do for us. You have to stop this with him, immediately.”

We talked some more, she cried some more. Our conversation bumping like a pinball from TN, to her next move, to my struggles with my ex and his new girlfriend who is overly fond of tagging him on FB with notes like, “My hot, hot boyfriend” and exchanging inside jokes with my old family, to her friendships that recently fell apart and back again to her safety, her fear, her pain. This was not bubblegum chit-chat. It was chewing on gravel and spitting out dust.

Then, naturally, TN popped his head out. My heart sank. He, caring about me, has known my heartbreak over her and she my heartbreak over him. I held my breath. They said hello and quickly warmed up to each other. He wasn’t leaving, I wasn’t inviting. I poured us some more wine and he noticed that we were almost out. “I still have some wine if you want some,” he offered.

My best friend and I looked at each other. I gave her the tiniest nod. “Why don’t you bring some over?” she suggested.

“Really? Ok! Hy, which kind do you want? The vintage we’ve had already or a new one?”

“Surprise me,” was my only response.

He disappeared into his dark apartment and my best friend asked if that was ok. I said it was. It wasn’t breaking any of my rules, we wouldn’t be alone together, and maybe she needed a distraction from our Big Girl Talk.

He brought the wine out onto the balcony that now only had two chairs instead of the usual four. He stood awkwardly for a minute then went to leave. I thanked him for the wine, the bottle tucked in my arm like a baby, and he shut the screen door.

“Well, I guess I’ll leave you two alone now,” he said with a droop, and in a heartbeat, my best friend invited him to drink with us. His face lit up and he looked me square in the eyes. “Really?? Is that ok?”

I held his gaze, my dark blue eyes to his icy ones. “Sure. Get a chair.”

He returned with the chair and sat down to my left, she was on my right. No sooner had his ass hit the chair than we all heard the pool fence clack and rattle and 3 women in bikinis, a small child, and a man came to the hot tub.

“Hey, hey, hey,” he said suggestively as he looked down over his shoulder.

My response was immediate and unfriendly, “Shut the fuck up, TN. Just shut. the. fuck. up.” This had been a mistake.

“What??” he asked, looking to my friend for assistance who looked at him with pure disdain.

“‘Shut the fuck up,’ I said.” I wrestled infinitesimally with myself. I had smacked him down hard, like a child. He sat frozen, waiting for what I would do next. I let the tension hang a beat more before I picked up the conversation and moved on. It didn’t feel right to make a scene and ruin what my best friend and I had so tenderly woven between us. I have learned to give TN more and more rope each day. Let him be a disrespectful prick. It only helps me.

We talked for some time, my friend sullen, yet trying to be open and present, and TN mooching whatever it was he needed from me for a couple more hours. It wasn’t unpleasant, but it was strange and somewhat forced, a pill that wouldn’t quite go down.

My poor, broken friend was in no mood to socialize in reality like I think she’d hoped, and I was in no mood to be gracious, yet there was a sense of dejá vu. She was my first conspirator in my affair with him and we spent countless hours together last winter in just this constellation of chairs, wine glasses and cigarette butts.

Eventually, he begged off, and I let him show himself out.

He passed through my apartment as he has hundreds of times before, but this time without so much as a wink, a rub, a touch, or an innuendo from me. My heart shriveled a little, a piece turned to ice. My hope dwindles away every passing minute.

My friend apologized and I assured her it was ok. I want nights like that to happen. I want him to see the “after.” I want this to be visceral, real, like realizing he’s burnt the fucking chicken on the grill. You can’t undo the char, motherfucker.

It took several weeks of polite distance from me for my best friend to realize what had happened, but what I learned is that I am capable of holding firm on my boundaries. I wasn’t trying to punish her, just as I’m not trying to punish TN. I’m simply done. “Hy, please get better boundaries,” she implored upon me. “Please.”

This last week with TN was a good start, but I know it was easy. I had Peyton, I was angry, I was filled with things to do, places to go, friends to see. Next week is Peyton’s father’s turn for two weeks straight. I am nervous. Polite distance, polite distance, polite distance. I repeat it over and over.

If he approaches me and asks what’s happened I will share, but, just like with my best friend, I’m done doing all the work. I am comfortable with taking a break for a change and watching what happens. This allows me time to wrap my head around a formal goodbye. Goodbye to the friendship, the chemistry, the cock, my heart, my hopes.

That cruel sliver of hope which always resides within me is only needle thin now; it’d be a robber’s moon if it shone anywhere but on my soul.

Yet shine it does. I would leap at the chance to see him be the man I know he could be — present, loving, all-in with me. Yes, even now. If he admitted he loved me and stood to face me he would be incredible. It makes my heart patter faster even typing this.

But I can’t take less. Not one inch less than, “I love you, Hyacinth. I am so sorry for everything I’ve said and done. I was such an idiot. Will you forgive me? I want to be the man in your life. I want to hold you when you cry and laugh with you when you’re beaming. I want to share my day with you and my hopes, thoughts, and fears and hear and hold all of yours. I want to see where this goes, Hy, and I am all yours. I love you.”

When my best friend and I finally gathered our battered selves together and crawled into my bed I gave her half my pills, put on a Frasier, and checked my phone. There was a text from TN from about an hour before he had shown his sweet, infuriating face. It read, “Busy tonight??”

I wish I’d seen it sooner.


A 40-something single mother who writes honestly about sex, body image, D/s, relationships, her nervous tics, and how much she loves to fucking fuck. She also likes to show you her tits.

You Might Also Like

47 thoughts on “The butterfly gives him more rope.
  1. Good for you! Keep that resolve! I love how you are kind to him, but firm on your boundaries! Keep it up! remember, you are a strong, beautiful, wonderful woman who deserves the very best!!!!!

  2. What an emotional rollercoaster.
    Lucky for your friend that you are so forgiving and open.

    “The person who is always there for everybody else is the most loneliest when by him/her self.”

    You’re such a giver, Hy. Just as finance is about the correlation between risk and return, life is, too, and your returns are looking marginal. I hope it looks up soon. Until then, take care of you! <3

  3. Beautiful post, as usual. You have drawn your line, you are in full control. I am pretty sad that TN story is coming to an end. I wish he could knock on your door right now, tears streaming down his face, bearing his love in full. Sigh…love to you.

  4. I’ve been wondering how you are doing. Hugs to you Hy. I wish I had words to make you feel better. I’m glad that your friend realized what was happening between you to and you guys had a good talk. That’s a good thing. Jayne

  5. You’re stronger, but don’t kid yourself, this guy is going to keep chipping away at yopur resolve until something breaks – or rather, until something opens…
    He knows he can pop in, get off and head out. When you think about it, you’ve created a selfish guy’s paradise: he gets what he wants, when he wants it, and for as long as he wants it.
    What do you get?
    Seriously, you can have crazy, wild, mind-blowing sex and blinding orgasms with ANYONE – of either sex – so why do you need this moron? And from what I’m, reading, he’s acting like a Grade-A moron, Hy.
    My advice? Take your time to find new place to live (You’ll never get any peace with this guy around) and then you can start over.
    No one likes to start over, but you need a fresh persepctive, Plus, if you found a new guy, he’d have to put up with TN’s presence in your life – and the downstairs neighbor as well – so you need some distance from this situation that has cropped up around you.
    Okay. I’m done – i think! This is longer than some of my posts… Sorry!

    1. Don’t apologize! I appreciate your thoughts on this.

      Unfortunately, I can’t move. It’s not financially possible. I’m going to have to do this the hard way.

      I like to imagine how great it’s going to feel when I accomplish my goal of ending things on my own. It’ll be a Herculean effort.

  6. I am so happy for you, and very proud, too. You are re-emerging as the strong, defiant woman I know is there. So exciting and wonderful to see her again.

    In tandem with her return, this is the most powerful writing in a long time. It reads like the best written novels. The angst, the re-self discovery, the determination, all the nuances. Superb!


  7. In my opinion, be it ever so humble, I think what makes you sad is the realization that the man you wanted TN to be is not an accurate representation of who he actually IS.

    TN is no more than a recalcitrant child. You say you want the cock, he says he’s not up for it. You say you’re the best girlfriend he never had, he takes the time to come up with six strikes. You say a lot of things to him and try to set a lot of boundaries and ground rules, and he completely ignores you. If there is a clearer indication that all he cares about is himself, I don’t know what it could be.

    Since the moment he said, out loud, that he takes you for granted, you’ve known that you need to pull up stakes and move on. What was the point of texting him your dream? At a certain point, you’re being a glutton for punishment. The only person you’re hurting is yourself. You need to mean more to you than TN does.

    You spend so much time trying to see the good in others that you completely pave over the bad with your mind. But no matter how you try to distort the reality and justify his behavior, his actions disprove your (blind) faith. You don’t have to think of him as a bad person, but logically you have to realize that he’s a bad person FOR YOU.

    Kicking the mat is just another example of his chronic lack of maturity. TN was probably that kid who, when he was told no, would come back later and do something vindictive so that he could feel better. Very passive aggressive. It’s all about control with him.

    He could have had it all with you, and he let it slip through his fingers. It’s a choice that he made, consciously and with a lot of thought, and you need to let it go. Not all dreams come true.

    With Peyton being gone for 2 weeks, what you need to do is start making plans. Make dates with men, go out with your friends, go hiking. You’ve already ascertained that it is harder for you to say no without Peyton around. Much like a recovering alcoholic needs to reprogram the “go to the bar” pattern, you need to do whatever it is you have to do to keep from falling back in to the rut.

    Build the wall Hy. When he steps on to your patio, build a wall. When he sends you a text, build a wall. When he comes over and cuddles on the couch in an effort to fuck, build a wall. When he comes over and cries about all the things he doesn’t have in his life, build a wall.

    He uses you for companionship at his whim (let’s hang out!), sex at his whim (fuck me!), a form of free therapy at his whim (listen to my problems!), a stylist at his whim (shop with me!).

    You get nothing from this other than orgasms that aren’t even given on a reliable basis.

    Is cumming really worth sacrificing so much?

    1. Hi Hy! I am new to your blog but have read all of it and feel like I know you! Funny I know! My two cents… I agree with Ella, so well said. Stand strong you deserve more and if we don’t close doors, others don’t open!!

  8. I read this last night right before I went to bed and drifted off to sleep with a smile on my face. I’m so proud of you my dear friend. Why? Because you’re being true to YOU. It goes against your habit of giving and giving and giving, which has to be difficult. But you did it. Celebration at my house? ; ) HUGS!!!!!

    1. Ha!

      As a stupid aside, I was on OK Cupid last night and saw that he was “online”. I had a little daymare about how he went on a date last night, but then I remembered that I WANT him to leave me alone and I want something better than what he’s giving me, so more power to him, blah blah blah, and this is going to suck monkey balls and I need to just sit in it like a steaming hot tub of the shit-reality that it is. :) Whew. I totally got a grip.

      Yes, at your house. Is tomorrow too soon? haha

  9. I’m so proud of you and SO HAPPY your best friend said those words, those perfect words: “Hy, you have to stop letting us take advantage of you. I’m glad you did this with me, I’ll never do it again. We don’t deserve you if we don’t value what you do for us. You have to stop this with him, immediately.”

  10. Ahhh I ‘m confused by the whole mat thing and the texting. When he said “flip it over” do you think he really meant flip it like the way you did (ie being jokey back) or did he mean flip it the way that would mean he loves you? Miscommunication via text? God this guy can’t handle you. No clue what to do with you.

      1. Hy that mat gesture really meant that – he MEANT to send that message? I wish somehow the pleasure you get from his body was in sync with his emotions or with his intentions towards you. It would make this easier on you. You know, he isn’t lying about his feelings…I don’t know if that helps cut the sting,but it could feel worse if he was lying to you so he could get laid. He doesn’t.

  11. Don’t let them use you all up. People forget that boundaries help them stay focused. You can’t bend over backwards/ say yes to everything. There’s no shame in doing something for you.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

CommentLuv badge

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.